Digital marketing for roofing, HVAC, plumbing, and restoration companies Talk to us: (888) 552-5453

The case goes to whoever picks up first.

Somebody is hurt, they or a family member start calling, and they stop calling as soon as one firm answers and sounds like it knows what happens next. Everything before that moment is marketing. Everything after it is intake. The two get judged as one number, and that is where most of the money goes missing.

Measured against cost per signed case, not cost per lead.

Attorney reviewing paperwork across the desk from an injured client in a neck brace

Ask the assistant who it would send your next customer to.

Pick your trade, type your city, and run the exact question a homeowner asks. If your company is not in the answer, that is the gap.

Your prompt

Who are the best roofing companies in Phoenix, AZ?

Open in ChatGPT

What actually goes wrong for personal injury firms.

Not generic marketing problems. The specific places a firm loses cases it had already paid to reach.

The cost is structural, not mismanaged
A single click on a car accident search ad can exceed $300 in a major market, because every firm bids the value of a signed case into the auction. Television, radio and billboards are saturated with firms spending seven figures a year. Working harder on the ads does not fix this
Volume arrives and does not sign
A standard lead-to-signed conversion runs 7 to 10 percent, and even exclusive files rarely exceed 20 percent. Between 80 and 90 percent of the investment disappears somewhere after the inquiry and before the retainer, which is exactly where most marketing reporting stops looking
A voicemail at 6pm is a case signed somewhere else by 9am
Firms measure investment per call constantly and answer time per source almost never
Four vendors, four numbers, no defensible one
When search, paid, brand and intake sit with different vendors, the partner signing the checks eventually stops believing any of the reporting. That is a rational response to it
The file settles a year after the campaign was turned off
By the time the fee arrives, the campaign that produced it has been changed twice or credited to something else

Of the cases you signed last quarter, how many can you trace back to the campaign that produced them?

Cost per lead and cost per signed case routinely disagree, and a source that looks cheap on the first is often the worst on the second. A firm optimizing the wrong one cuts its best channel and does not find out for two quarters. In a business where one file can carry a year, that is the number that decides where everything else goes.

If that is the picture, here is what the work looks like.

What we run for personal injury firms.

01

Visibility where the searching happens

Practice area and injury-type pages built for how somebody actually searches after an accident, plus the structured facts that decide whether an assistant names your firm when a family asks who to call. This is Search Visibility Architecture, the Demand layer.

02

Paid search priced against signed cases

Not cost per click. Not cost per form. The number we report against is what a signed file costs you, by source, because that is the only one that survives contact with a P&L.

03

Reputation as a growth channel

Reviews decide the click in a category where nobody has an existing relationship with any firm on the page. Review velocity and response discipline are marketing work, not administrative work.

04

Intake measured, not assumed

Answer time tracked by source, calls recorded and scored, and the gap between calls received and cases signed made visible monthly instead of surfacing as a bad quarter. This is the Capture layer, and in this practice area it is usually where the return is.

05

Attribution that survives the file

Every call and form matched into your case management system, so the source stays attached to the matter through settlement rather than expiring at intake. This is the Revenue layer.

100+
Active home services clients across North America
50+
Years combined experience on the team
1,000s
Of calls tracked every month
5.0
Average rating across verified Clutch reviews

Cost per signed case is the only number we report against.

A firm investing $40,000 in a month and signing 20 cases is at $2,000 per signed case. That figure moves for three reasons and only three: the mix of what you are visible for, how fast and how well intake answers, and whether the reporting lets you tell a good source from a cheap one. We work those three in that order, and we show you the number every month whether it improved or not.

Cost per lead
What an agency reports. Easy to move, easy to make look good, and disconnected from fee revenue
Cost per signed case
What you actually run the firm on. Investment divided by files that cleared liability, damages and coverage screening
Answer time by source
The variable almost nobody tracks and the one most likely to be losing you cases you already paid for
Source at settlement
Whether the campaign that produced a fee is still identifiable when the fee arrives

What we will tell you before you sign anything.

Case acquisition in this practice area is expensive and it does not get cheaper by working harder on the ads. It gets cheaper when intake stops leaking, when the firm is visible for the injury types it actually wants rather than all of them, and when the reporting separates the files worth having from the ones that consume a paralegal and settle for nothing. If the first conversation shows the problem is intake rather than marketing, we will say so, and it will probably cost us the engagement.

Questions firms ask

How do personal injury law firms generate leads without buying shared leads?

By being the firm a family finds and trusts at the moment they start looking, which means practice area visibility, review strength, and an intake that answers. Shared and resold files put you in a race with three other firms over the same person, and that race is decided on speed rather than on fit.

What is a good cost per signed case?

It depends on your injury mix, your market, and your average fee per file. One published model runs a growing firm from $1,200 down to $1,000 per signed case while annual investment rises from $120,000 to $250,000. We model against your numbers rather than quoting a figure that may describe a very different practice.

Why is cost per lead not the right metric?

Because a source can be cheap per inquiry and terrible per signed file. With standard conversion running 7 to 10 percent, most of what you pay for never becomes a case, so a metric that stops at the inquiry hides the part that matters.

How do you track marketing through a case that takes a year to resolve?

The source attaches to the matter, not to the form. Every call and form is matched into your case management system so the campaign that produced a file is still identifiable at settlement.

Can marketing improve case quality rather than just volume?

Yes, and that is usually where the return is. Targeting by injury type, and page content written for the file you want, changes who calls. Volume is the easier problem and the more expensive one to solve.

What if the problem turns out to be intake rather than marketing?

We will tell you, and we will show you the answer times by source that led us to say it. Selling campaigns into a leaking intake produces one bad quarter and one former client.

Find out what is producing your best work.

Fill out the form for a free analysis.

  • Your visibility where your buyers actually look
  • Which channels produce the work you want more of
  • What you cannot currently trace back to a source
  • What we would fix first
Request your attribution review
Six fields. No sales call to get it.

Prefer to talk? (888) 552-5453

Let's Talk!

Start your FREE Website Review and receive a FREE Consultation. Use the form below or call us at (888) 552-5453 today!